I want to look at each of the images used for yesterday's animation sequence. Each of the similarities, I mean. But I'm having a hell of a time getting started with the writing. So I'm gonna just start.
Image #1: No lag... Similarity: January 1919 - November 1930
| Graph #1: No Lag |
I will describe a "lag" in terms of how many months I have to offset the Base Money (black) graph to the right to obtain a highlightable period of similarity. I will describe a "similarity" using the dates of the Inflation (red) graph, the one that doesn't move back and forth thru time.
The similarity highlighted in Graph #1 ends suddenly in late 1930, when it appears the Federal Reserve suddenly decided to do something about the Great Depression. Just after the yellow highlight ends, base money (black) shoots up while the rate of inflation falls for six months more (till June 1931) and then drags bottom at -10% till March 1933.
That separation of the lines shows the lag developing.
Image #2: Lag 29 months... Similarity March 1933 - March 1934
| Graph #2: Base Money Lagged Two Years |
At the start of that similarity the lag (November 1930 to March 1933) was 28 months. By the end of that similarity, it was 29 months. I'll call it 29 months.
Image #3: Lag 50 months... Similarity March 1934 - May 1937
| Graph #3: Base Money Lagged Four Years |
Note -- This image has been revised. Originally I showed one yellow stripe of highlight, running through those modest peaks. (You can see that version in yesterday's post.)
Incidentally, the peaks that end Similarity #2 no longer appear aligned because on Graph #3, base money (black) is shifted two additional years to the right. (If that doesn't make sense, go fiddle with the interactive experiment graph again.)
The end of this similarity is the highlighted peak of the black line in March 1933. And for the red line, in May 1937. The difference -- the time the black line is lagged -- is 50 months.
Image #4: Lag 63 months... Similarity May 1937 - October 1938
| Graph #4: Base Money Lagged Five Years |
For the black line it starts with the end of Sim #3 (March 1933) and ends in July 1933.
For the red line it starts with the end of Sim #3 (May 1937) and ends in October 1938.
It's a challenge to get the dates right on these graphs, what with these images lagged (but not providing pop-up info windows) and the FRED graph providing the info windows (with nothing lagged). It's making my head spin. Hey, if you see anything that looks like a mistake, let me know.
Image #5: Lag 92 months... Similarity October 1938 - March 1951
| Graph #5: Base Money Lagged Seven Years |
Where to end this similarity? For the black line I'm gonna go with the high point in the third tall spike in the group of three, so July 1943
For the red line I'm gonna stop it at the top of the third red spike of three, March 1951.
The highlighting is a bit off from these dates that I'm choosing now. It's a little bit arbitrary, choosing the dates. If you know a better way to figure it, do let me know.
(It's completely arbitrary.)
Image #6: Lag 74 months... Similarity March 1951 - March 1955
| Graph #6: Base Money Lagged Six Years |
For the red line, start at March 1951. And end at, I'll say March 1955
For the red line, I start Similarity #6 where #5 ended. For the black line I'm leaving a little gap. Number six starts at the black peak where the yellow highlight starts. But number five ended at the nearby, higher, slightly earlier peak. So there is a brief gap between similarities at that point.
Note that other than this brief gap, and the dis-similarity described under Image #1, there are no gaps where one similarity ends and the next one begins. Granted, this is all by eye, and arbitrary. But these "similarities" are nothing but short sections of the overall graph, short enough that we can compare them and describe them.
But if the similarities connect like railroad cars, then what we're seeing is that the pattern of the red graph and the pattern of the black graph are actually quite strikingly similar. The main difference between the two lines is nothing more than a lag -- a long and variable lag. And I'm thinking that the best way to show similarity would be with an "accordion axis" if I knew how to make such a thing.
I'm also thinking that this accordion axis would essentially be a standard axis modified by a calculation that shortens or lengthens the time units in an irregular pattern. I want to create such an axis, because I want to take that calculation and see what it looks like as a normal graph. If it has a familiar look, if it reminds us of something, then perhaps we will have found a major component of the rise and fall of this lag.
Image #7: Lag 60 months... Similarity March 1955 - May 1960
| Graph #7: Base Money Lagged Five Years |

I figured these start- and stop-points by looking for similarities in the patterns. Tomorrow I'll graph the lag lengths.

.png)




